Link to the homepage of the Hong Kong Polytechnic University

MA ELT Dissertation

An Investigation into Learners’ Disposition and Perceived Ability to Learn Independently in the Centre for Independent Language Learning

Grade received: 'B'


Abstract of a dissertation entitled:

An Investigation into Learners’ Disposition and Perceived Ability to Learn Independently in the Centre for Independent Language Learning

submitted by Andrew J. Morrall

for the M.A. in English Language Teaching

at the Hong Kong Polytechnic University in January 1998.

This investigation looks at the learner training (LT) desired by students in the Centre for Independent Language Learning (CILL) of Hong Kong Polytechnic University (HKPU). Previous research in CILL into the need for LT showed that further investigation was necessary. Although there is widespread agreement in the literature about the importance of learner training, there are a variety of possibilities for implementing a learner training program.

The main aims of this investigation are, firstly, to identify the disposition towards independent language learning of CILL students and secondly to identify the perceived ability in independent language learning of these students. A sub-aim is to investigate whether the amount of CILL experience of the students changes their dispositions and perceived abilities systematically. This will contribute to the third main aim, which is to judge whether further learner training for these students is needed or wanted, and what options CILL could offer.

The hypotheses were that firstly, CILL students would have a favourable disposition towards independent language learning in CILL, which was confirmed in the interviews, as was the second hypothesis, that students would, in general, be satisfied with their independent learning (IL) abilities in the CILL context. The third hypothesis was that students’ disposition towards IL and their perceived ability to learn independently would increase with the duration of their total attendance in CILL. While this hypothesis was not supported by the data from the questionnaire, it was supported by the students’ statements in the interviews. The final hypothesis was that further LT opportunities would be wanted by the students. This was also confirmed.

Data was collected by a questionnaire completed by 30 students, by interviewing six students, and then searching for evidence in the Learner Diaries of the interviewees.

It was concluded that although there is great emphasis in the literature on LT, factors such as overwhelming workloads and satisfaction with their present perceived abilities may limit students’ desire to spend time on LT.

A range of short-duration LT opportunities is therefore recommended. LT opportunities available in CILL could be pointed out to new students during the orientation; how to decide an aim should be given more explanation in the orientation; the new ‘Guided Independent Language Learning Scheme’ (GILLS) could include LT as one of its aims; first year students could be especially targeted in the membership drive for GILLS; and if this LT in GILLS is successful, further research could be done on what additional LT the students would like.

Finally, it is suggested that although staff in other self-access centres may find this research informative, they should conduct their own research into their learners’ desires for LT. Another possibility is research into LT across HK self-access centres.


Acknowledgements:

I would like to thank my dissertation supervisor, Mr Richard Farmer, the Lecturer in Charge of my Centre, Mr. Bruce Morrison, the technical staff of CILL for their help in distributing questionnaires, my statistics advisor Mr. K. P. Kwan, and my wife for her patience and understanding.


List of Tables

2.1 Users’ Perceptions of the Appropriateness of Self-access language Learning for Chinese Learners (Gardner & Miller 1997: 44)
2.2 Sheerin’s (1997: 57) model of activities involved in independent learning.
2.3 Nunan’s (1997: 195) model ‘Autonomy: levels of implementation.’
2.4 A comparison of Sheerin’s (1997: 57) model of ‘Activities involved in independent learning’ (on the left) with her (1997: 59) ‘Attitudinal statements on independent learning’.
2.5 Definitions of Surface, Deep and Achieving Approaches (Gow & Kember 1990: 309)

 

List of Figures

Page

3.1 The Main Questionnaire

 

List of Appendices

1. Pilot Questionnaire
2. Pilot Questionnaire Statistics
3. Graph of the linear relationship between the variables ‘Duration’ and ‘Perceived Ability’
4. Questionnaire Statistics
5. Visual Aid for Interviews: Screen shot of the main page of the ‘How to Improve Your English in CILL’ program.
6. Visual Aid for Interviews: Screen shot of the CILL home page
7. Transcript of the Pilot Interview
8. Transcript of the Second Interview
9. Transcript of the Third Interview
10. Transcript of the Fourth Interview
11. Transcript of the Fifth Interview
12. Transcript of the Sixth Interview
13. Supporting Evidence from the Diary of the First Interviewee
14. Supporting Evidence from the Diary of the Second Interviewee
15. Supporting Evidence from the Diary of the Third Interviewee
16. Supporting Evidence from the Diary of the Fourth Interviewee
17. Supporting Evidence from the Diary of the Fifth Interviewee
18. Supporting Evidence from the Diary of the Sixth Interviewee

Last revised on Tuesday, August 28, 2012

If you have any comments, please contact Andy Morrall at ecandym@polyu.edu.hk